VS
Try Popular Comparisons
Our recommendation
Ather Energy 450S 2.9 kWh
Good choice.
Best overall
Ather Energy 450S 2.9 kWh
Higher total score
Best value
Ather Energy 450S 2.9 kWh
Lower ex-showroom price
Best range
Ola Electric S1 Pro 4 kWh
Higher claimed range
Ex-showroom price
₹1,49,999₹14,000 cheaper
₹1,35,999✓ Winner
EMI from
₹3,950/mo
₹3,581/mo
Claimed range
242 km✓ Winner
122 km
Real-world range
155–165 km
90–105 km
Battery capacity
4 kWh
2.9 kWh
Charge time
4 hrs✓ Winner
5.5 hrs
Top speed
130 km/h✓ Winner
90 km/h
Boot space
34 L✓ Winner
22 L
Kerb weight
113 kgLighter = better
108 kg✓ Winner
Ground clearance
160 mm
170 mm✓ Winner
Seat height
791 mm
780 mm
Value for money
5.3
6.9✓ Winner
Ride quality
7.5
9.5✓ Winner
Service network
6.5
9✓ Winner
Category breakdown
S1 Pro 4 kWh
450S 2.9 kWh
Which should you actually buy?
Straight talk. No hedging.
Ola Electric
S1 Pro 4 kWh
Buy if: Best range (181 km), largest boot (36L), most tech. The complete city commuter package.
Avoid if: Avoid if you're in a Tier-2 city with limited Ola service, or prefer physical controls.
Ather Energy
450S 2.9 kWh
Buy if: Good choice.
Avoid if: Check service availability.
Who should NOT buy each
Equally important as who should buy.
Don't buy S1 Pro 4 kWh if…
Tier-2 city buyers without Ola service
Buyers who prefer physical controls
Don't buy 450S 2.9 kWh if…
Buyers needing large boot (>22L)
Outside Ather service network