Side-by-side comparison
S1 X+ 4 kWh vs 450S 2.9 kWh (2026)
Complete specs, real-world range, expert verdict — with a clear winner.
Popular:
VS
🔥 Try Popular Comparisons
🏅 Best overall
Ola Electric S1 X+ 4 kWh
Higher total score
💰 Best value
Ather Energy 450S 2.9 kWh
Lower ex-showroom price
🔋 Best range
Ola Electric S1 X+ 4 kWh
Higher claimed range
💰 Price & Value
Ex-showroom price
₹124,999₹4,158 cheaper
₹120,841✓ Winner
EMI from
₹3,250/mo
₹3,142/mo
🔋 Range & Charging
Claimed range
242 km✓ Winner
122 km
Real-world range
180–200 km
90–105 km
Battery capacity
4 kWh
2.9 kWh
Charge time
4.5 hrs✓ Winner
5 hrs
⚡ Performance
Top speed
90 km/h✓ Winner
90 km/h
Motor power
undefined
undefined
Torque
undefined
undefined
📦 Practicality
Boot space
34 L✓ Winner
22 L
Kerb weight
108 kgLighter = better
108 kg✓ Winner
Ground clearance
155 mm
155 mm✓ Winner
Seat height
785 mm
785 mm
⭐ Our Scores (out of 10)
Range
10✓ Winner
5.5
Features
9✓ Winner
8.5
Value for money
6.7
6.9✓ Winner
Ride quality
7.5
9.5✓ Winner
Service network
6.5
9✓ Winner
Category breakdown
S1 X+ 4 kWh
450S 2.9 kWh
Which should you actually buy?
Straight talk. No hedging.
❌ Who should NOT buy each
Equally important as who should buy.
🚫 Don't buy S1 X+ 4 kWh if…
Tier-2 city buyers without Ola service
Buyers who prefer physical controls
🚫 Don't buy 450S 2.9 kWh if…
Buyers needing large boot (>22L)
Outside Ather service network